October 2020

Buy Fretzels by Jill Original Assortment One Dozen Box, $29

fretzels-250

Buy Fretzels by Jill Original Assortment One Dozen Box, $29, at fretzels.com

  • Milk-, white-, and dark-chocolate-covered pretzels with assorted toppings
  • If serving or giving, assume 2–3 Fretzels per person
  • Custom orders available
  • Fretzel of the Month Club: $75–$529

Shop the Full Story:
Get Your Sugar Fix: The Top 5 Sweet Treats You Have to Try

Buy Garrett Popcorn Shops CaramelCrisp & CheeseCorn, $56, $84, $135

garrett-250

Buy Garrett Popcorn Shops CaramelCrisp & CheeseCorn, $56 (2 gal.), $84 (3.5 gal.), $135 (6.5 gal.), at garrettpopcorn.com

  • Tins come in 10 different designs
  • Available in 3 sizes—2, 3.5, and 6.5 gallons
  • Two most popular flavors side-by-side
  • 12 additional flavors and combinations

Shop the Full Story:
Get Your Sugar Fix: The Top 5 Sweet Treats You Have to Try

Get Your Sugar Fix: The Top 5 Sweet Treats You Have to Try

By Lindsay Hahn

We know. The last thing you need is another delectable sugary indulgence to have to say “no” to. But who would we be if we didn’t share our latest discoveries, sweets or any other kind? And while we love Halloween just like the next girl, these treats will satisfy our sweet tooth year-round. From melt-in-your-mouth cinnamon rolls, to chocolate-covered pretzels topped with toffee bits, to pecan coconut bars, this batch of gourmet goodies makes the perfect hostess gift, party dessert, or personal stash. So whether you give, serve, or hoard them, our top 5 sweets picks will have everyone smiling.

1. Fretzels by Jill
Fretzels take chocolate-covered pretzels to a whole new—gourmet—level. As if this salty-sweet treat weren’t perfect enough, wait until you taste it covered in toppings such as M&Ms, peanut butter chips, or buttery toffee bits. Converts can join the Fretzel of the Month Club for new specialty flavors year-round.
PageDaily Favorite: Original Assortment One Dozen Box
Buy Fretzels by Jill Original Assortment One Dozen Box, $29, at fretzels.com

2. Ivy Bakery’s Cinnamon Rolls
Forget about the worm . . . Early birds will score big getting to Brooklyn-based Ivy Bakery at first light, before the daily batch of out-of-this-world cinnamon rolls is gone. We’re obsessed with the original—light dough twirled with cinnamon and doused in glaze. For a fall flavor kick, try pumpkin spice or caramel apple variety. Not in the New York area? No worries. Ivy ships many of its 300-plus other treats anywhere in the U.S.
PageDaily Favorite: Cinnamon Rolls
Buy Ivy Bakery Cinnamon Rolls, $36 (12 rolls), email mail@ivybakery.com or call 347.598.3452

3. Lisa’s Cookie Shop Gourmet Snacks
It’s not easy to buy something to eat that’s as good—or better—than homemade. But Lisa’s Cookie Shop, started by Lisa Ciriello, combines crowd-pleasing recipes and superior ingredients for cookies and bars that have us licking the crumbs off our fingers. From chocolate-chip cookies to raspberry bars to the best-selling Kitchen Sink Cookies, these goodies will make you feel as if you’ve landed back in grandma’s kitchen.
PageDaily Favorite: Pecan Coconut Bars
Buy Lisa’s Cookie Shop Pecan Coconut Bars, $7.50 (4 bars), at lisascookieshop.com

4. Gourmetibles Gourmet Treats
It’s indulgence time. Which way do you go? Cookie, candy. Candy, cookie. How excited were we to solve this dessert dilemma when we stumbled upon Gourmetibles. These wafer-thin cookies come slathered in butterscotch, dark chocolate, or peanut butter, and sprinkled with toppings such as almonds, walnuts, or marshmallows! For the serious sugar addict, try More than S’Mores or Pep’Mint Power, and for that salty-sweet fix, go with PB and Pretzel.
PageDaily Favorite: Beyond Butterscotch
Buy Gourmetibles Beyond Butterscotch, $9.99 (1/2 lb.) and $18.99 (1 lb.), at gourmetible.com

5. Garrett Popcorn Shops
When popcorn goes sweet, we go wild. And you will too with Garrett’s addictive popcorn, in flavors such as cashew, almond, or pecan. Don’t miss Garrett’s CarmelCrisp & CheeseCorn combination tin for a full blast of the two most popular flavors. Whether you snack on them together or separately, this savory-sweet popcorn mix will leave you wanting more.
PageDaily Favorite: CaramelCrisp & CheeseCorn
Buy Garrett Popcorn Shops CaramelCrisp & CheeseCorn, $56 (2 gal.), $84 (3.5 gal.), $135 (6.5 gal.), at garrettpopcorn.com

For more on the PageDaily team’s snacking obsession, read Editor-in-Chief Nancy Rotenier’s blog post, The Food Police Fesses Up: My Snacking Confession.

Buy Lisa’s Cookie Shop Pecan Coconut Bars, $7.50

lisa's-cookie-shop-250

Buy Lisa’s Cookie Shop Pecan Coconut Bars, $7.50 (4 bars), at lisascookieshop.com

  • A shortbread crust topped with a mixture of coconut, brown sugar, and pecans
  • All treats baked to order
  • Samplers and gift baskets available

Shop the Full Story:
Get Your Sugar Fix: The Top 5 Sweet Treats You Have to Try

Buy Ivy Bakery Cinnamon Rolls, $36

ivy-bakery-250

Buy Ivy Bakery Cinnamon Rolls, $36 (12 rolls), email mail@ivybakery or call 347.598.3452

  • Homemade
  • Custom orders available in 30 flavors, including pumpkin spice, caramel apple, and blueberry
  • Cinnamon rolls only available for delivery or pickup in New York

Shop the Full Story:
Get Your Sugar Fix: The Top 5 Sweet Treats You Have to Try

Buy Gourmetibles Beyond Butterscotch, $9.99, $18.99

gourmetibles-250

Buy Gourmetibles Beyond Butterscotch, $9.99 (1/2 lb.) and $18.99 (1 lb.), at gourmetible.com

  • Wafer-thin cookie slathered in butterscotch and topped with chopped macadamia nuts
  • Crumble on ice cream, yogurt, or oatmeal for a sweet crunch
  • Available in 6 varieties, including S’mores Blizzard and Way Out Walnut
  • Peanut Butter Pretzel and Way Out Walnut now available in gluten-free

Shop the Full Story:
Get Your Sugar Fix: The Top 5 Sweet Treats You Have to Try